San Marco Ristorante
Amherst, NY 14226

For more than 35 years the owners have delighted guests from Western New York and around the world with the wonderful flavors of Italian cuisine and devotion to excellent service. San Marco is Buffalo’s top restaurant in Northern Italian cuisine.
Traveler Rating

Five Most Recent Traveler Reviews
Reservation Not Honored - Treated Rudely By Owner
Good friends mentioned to me that they had never been to San Marco; I had also not been there in quite some time. I called and made a reservation about 3 weeks in advance for Saturday, July 20 at...
Excellent Italian dining!
Don’t be fooled by the exterior appearance of this restaurant, once inside it is simply amazing. Where we were seated, it was like we were in a wine cellar, without the cold damp feeling. Food was...
Awful
This place is not what it used to be. Salty food, weird waiter, super loud in the restaurant, had to call 3x for a reservation because they never “had the book”. Last time we will ever go there.
Phenomenal Italian Cuisine!
Phenomenal food! We have been here as a couple and have had our staff dinner here. The food is so good that you will dream about the next time you have it. Between the quality ingredients and the...
Great dining experience
Very nice meal at San Marco last night. Hadn't been here for long time. Beautiful room, lovely food, personable server. Yeah, the owner is not a warm friendly type, but I'd hardly call him "rude...