Hibbard’s Custard

105 Portage Road
Lewiston, NY 14092
(716) 754-4218 hfhibbard@gmail.com Visit Website

Hibbard’s has been in business since the 1930s and the same family has owned and operated the stand for four generations. They make fresh frozen custard every day and thanks to special machinery, a significantly less amount of air gets pumped into the custard making the texture amazingly creamy.

Traveler Rating

TripAdvisor
  • 4.0 Atmosphere
  • 4.5 Value
  • 4.5 Service
  • 4.5 Food

Five Most Recent Traveler Reviews

5.0 09/13/2022 | By jakk281
GREAT CUSTARD

We had the peach custard and the raspberry custard. For people who think this is just ice cream, they are in for a treat. Very creamy and fantastic flavors. A little on the pricey side, but well...

Show More

5.0 07/14/2022 | By soulefultraveler
3 years later - still outstanding

They had plenty of welcoming staff. Same wonderful quality. A real hit with families all summer. Worth a detour to check it out.

Show More

5.0 06/29/2022 | By Meander38912210264
Delicious treat!

After having dinner @ Brickyard Pub & BBQ, we hurried over to grab a quick treat. Even though they were to close at 9pm, they served everyone in line...even after 9. Good selection of flavors!

Show More

4.0 04/24/2022 | By O1062DJjessicad
Great frozen custard

I had pistachio custard and it was delicious! My husband had a chocolate peanut butter cup mix (like a blizzard). He was disappointed it wasn’t Reese’s cups though.

Show More

5.0 08/29/2021 | By Sakvanichpong
Yumminess near Niagara!

This ice cream shop came highly recommended and it was actually really good. The portions were good for the price and the flavors were awesome. The kids loved it. The custard and the hard ice cream...

Show More

Write a Review
Business image
Business image
Business image

Hibbard’s Custard

×
Leaflet | © OpenStreetMap contributors © CARTO